Collier County Newsletter Top Featured

Special counsel report finds problems at Mason Classical Academy


What’s going on behind closed doorways at Mason Classical Academy?

A report from the Faculty District of Collier County particular counsel found a scarcity of monetary oversight, Sunshine Regulation violations and mismanagement by some administrators.

“We listened to a lot of people and those people included parents, faculty members,” Fishbane stated.

Now, Special Counsel Joe Fishbane has referred to as for two of the board members for the charter faculty to resign. His report comes after MCA’s former Treasurer Jon Baird complained to the state.

“All they wanted was to hide everything from me,” Fishbane stated.

The state advised the Faculty District of Collier County to take a better look.

“When things got bad enough,” Fishbane stated, “that’s when I looked at the situation and I said, ‘I have to do something.’”

Fishbane’s report appears at past emails, conferences and knowledge from witnesses accusing the academy of breaking its charter contract by not having a finance committee in place since 2015, along with the administration of mistreating mother and father and students.

Fishbane recommends coaching, a change in management and a evaluation of the board of operations, slightly than closing the varsity. Baird agrees, telling WINK Information constitution faculties have to be higher held accountable.

“You can’t look away,” Fishbane stated. “They have to be addressed and something needs to happen.”


Mason Classical Academy sent the following in response to a press release:

Pricey Mason Classical Academy Group,

Mason Classical Academy has been a tremendous success story since it first opened its doorways in 2014. All the staff of students, mother and father, academics, employees and board of administrators are to be recommended for his or her perseverance and willingness to study the true, do the great and love the gorgeous.  As with all worthwhile achievement, the journey has not been with out its challenges.  There have been many uphill battles, particularly at first, but probably the most unimaginable moment occurred in Might of 2014 once we have been registering tons of of scholars at Sports activities Membership.  Faculty was scheduled to begin in mid-August, and we have been registering students and not using a facility.  That’s proper, we have been months away from the first day of faculty and we had not but secured an actual constructing to carry courses.  We had no concept there can be so many mother and father prepared to take that leap of religion with us.  The varsity was principally simply an concept at that time.  What an astounding testament to the facility of a father or mother’s want for the very best for their baby.

As chances are you’ll know, there have been many different challenges for the varsity since its opening.  The district tried to non-renew our constitution in 2017 after a pretend news story appeared within the paper about low interest loan provides being refused – which by no means occurred. No comply with up story was ever revealed. There were hoaxes within the news regarding potty training accidents – which never occurred.  No comply with up story was ever aired.  A Division of Youngsters and Family Providers investigation into alleged misconduct story appeared within the native paper – no misconduct was uncovered. No comply with up story was ever revealed.

Corrupt board members have come and gone.  One had to resign after it was discovered that he was benefiting from loans that the varsity took from a trust he was invested in.  One other resigned underneath a cloud of suspicion that he might have violated Sunshine Laws during his try and unseat the board chair with the unlawful and unethical promise of low curiosity loans in trade for the chair’s resignation.

In June 2018, the Florida Division of Schooling forwarded a grievance that they acquired from a former Mason Classical Academy (MCA) father or mother to Collier County Public Faculties (CCPS).  Quickly after receiving the grievance, CCPS lawyer, Jon Fishbane, began compiling complaints concerning the faculty and its leaders.

On October 5, 2018, MCA first discovered of Mr. Fishbane’s efforts by way of a Naples Every day News article.  The article states, partially: “Jennifer Kupiec, spokeswoman for Collier schools, said in an email that the district is ‘carefully’ looking into Baird’s concerns but did not provide more details about how the investigation is being conducted.”

On multiple events, between October 2018 and April 2019, the MCA board and its lawyer, Shawn Arnold, requested updates on the progress of the Fishbane investigation.  Having full information of the allegations contained within the former father or mother’s grievance, the MCA board hired an outdoor accounting agency, McCrady and Associates, to look at the varsity’s funds.  The agency found no evidence of any financial mismanagement.

In April 2019, Mr. Fishbane, by means of MCA’s lawyer, informed the varsity that he was not accepting any documentation from MCA “unless it is extraordinary.”  Mr. Fishbane additionally informed MCA that he can be completing his investigation “in three weeks.”  By this time, Mr. Fishbane had not interviewed a single MCA worker or board member.

Due Process

Mr. Fishbane meant to release his report with out visiting the varsity, without interviewing any staff or board members or inspecting any data in the faculty’s possession.  When pressed on the merits of an investigation absent the foregoing elements, Mr. Fishbane agreed to interview one employee, David Hull.  None of Mr. Hull’s statements have been included in Mr. Fishbane’s June three, 2019 report to the CCPS board.  Nor have been any of the themes addressed within the report mentioned during Mr. Hull’s interview.  By any truthful measure, not one of the subjects of Mr. Fishbane’s investigation have been afforded due process.  Whether you’re supportive of the management at MCA or not, definitely all People can agree that we must be afforded due process when being accused of wrongdoing.

Mr. Fishbane’s Report to the CCPS Board

Mr. Fishbane’s unredacted report to the CCPS board was emailed to the MCA board and its lawyer on June three, 2019.  The report was summarized at the June four, 2019 CCPS board assembly during Mr. Fishbane’s closing feedback.  The redacted report, which Mr. Fishbane committed to supply at the June 4thCCPS board meeting, has not yet been posted.  It’s alarming that the unredacted version was launched by the district, as it accommodates personally identifiable scholar knowledge, which is protected by the Family Instructional Rights and Privateness Act (FERPA) of 1974.

Mr. Fishbane’s report incorporates quite a few allegations towards the MCA board and its principal.  It also consists of several recommendations for remediation, including the removing of the varsity’s board and principal.  So far, CCPS has not made any demands of or made any suggestions to the MCA board. Only the CCPS board could make demands of or suggestions to the MCA board.  Mr. Fishbane’s report, including its conclusions and proposals, are merely his report to the CCPS board.  The CCPS board, as they plainly admitted throughout their June 4thmeeting, doesn’t have the authority to demand the removing or inclusion of any charter faculty board member or principal.

Hillsdale School

On June 6, 2019, in response to Mr. Fishbane’s allegations, Hillsdale School despatched aletter to the MCA board.  Prior to talking with anyone at MCA concerning the report, the school’s new provost wrote that he agreed with Mr. Fishbane’s suggestions and demanded that MCA comply, or face dropping its contractual relationship with the varsity.  Per MCA’s contract with Hillsdale, they need to give prior written notice to the MCA board 60 days previous to terminating its contractual settlement with MCA.  But we absolutely intend to revive our relationship with the school.

Right now, Hillsdale shouldn’t be but aware that Mr. Fishbane’s investigation lacked any testimony from the accused and sought no documentation from the varsity. We consider Hillsdale’s newly installed provost, Chris VanOrman, was merely caught off guard, had no information of the political environment in Collier County, and had a knee-jerk reaction to Mr. Fishbane’s report.  The MCA board is aware of Hillsdale absolutely supports the U.S. Structure and will continue to pursue fact and defend liberty.

It also needs to be famous that the Hillsdale letter was only despatched to the MCA board, Mr. Adam Miller (FDOE) and Mr. Fishbane.  It is alarming that this letter was leaked to the public before MCA had a chance to speak with Hillsdale.

MCA Board Assembly

The board chair, Kelly Lichter, was overseas on trip when the report was released and immediately scheduled a Special Board Assembly for June 8, 2019 at 12:00 pm to debate what actions the MCA board should take.  At that assembly, the board members heard public comment, and addressed the Fishbane report and the letter from Hillsdale School by directing Shawn Arnold to draft a response to both events.

The MCA Board’s Official Response

The Mason Classical Academy governing board is in receipt of Mr. Fishbane’s report to the Collier County Public Faculty board.  The governing board is disturbed and astounded by Mr. Fishbane’s allegations and takes them very significantly.  Nevertheless, we aren’t prepared to behave on Mr. Fishbane’s suggestions at this time.  If the governing board ever succumbs to the “recommendations” of a corrupt system, MCA will stop to exist and the brand new “district approved” board will basically change each facet of the varsity.

As MCA’s sponsor and an company that has retained a considerable proportion of the varsity’s annual income for administrative and educational providers since 2014, we are somewhat dismayed that CCPS has nevercommunicated any of the considerations alleged in Mr. Fishbane’s June 3rdreport.  For 5 years we have now been beneath the district’s watchful eye as a high performing constitution faculty.  At no time in the course of the faculty’s existence has the district ever expressed any of the considerations or legal allegations contained in Mr. Fishbane’s report.

Nonetheless, because of the seriousness of Mr. Fishbane’s allegations and MCA’s dedication to pursuing fact, the governing board has a proper and duty to research these allegations.  We should do what is in the most effective interest of the varsity and we owe it to the group to show the reality, no matter that could be.  In the direction of that finish, the governing board has voted to rent an investigative regulation firm to examine the contents of the report.  This agency will conduct a radical, unbiased, unbiased and proper investigation into each allegation contained in the Fishbane report.

Once this course of is full, a complete report might be offered to the mother and father of MCA, CCPS and Hillsdale School.  MCA may also host a public assembly the place the regulation agency will present their findings to the mother and father and basic public.  A query and reply session will comply with the presentation of this unbiased investigation.  The assembly will probably be video recorded and made obtainable online as properly.

Finally, permitting a faculty district to dictate who cannotand who canserve or work for a privately governed constitution faculty is a precedent that this governing board is unwilling to set.  MCA’s governing board believes in the elementary precept of due course of – a right endowed to us by our creator and enumerated in the U.S. Structure’s 5thand 14thamendment.

Please know that the continued success of Mason Classical Academy is of paramount significance to the governing board, and we’ll do the whole lot inside our power and authority to guard the varsity’s mission and viability.  Thank you in your continued prayers and help.


Board of Directors

Mason Classical Academy

We also talked with Hillsdale School in Michigan, which helps Mason Classical Academy. It stated no comment.